Filson Tin Cloth Cruiser vs Sugar Cane Hunting Jacket: Which One Wins?

If you are looking for a durable and stylish jacket that can withstand the elements and last for years, you might be interested in two popular options: the Filson Tin Cloth Cruiser and the Sugar Cane Brown Canvas Hunting Jacket.

Both jackets are made from heavy-duty cotton fabrics that are treated to resist water and abrasion, and both have a classic design that evokes the heritage of American outdoor wear.

But which one is better for you? Filson or Sugar Cane?

In this article, we will compare the two jackets in terms of their fabric, design, quality, and fit, and help you decide which one suits your needs and preferences.


You can wear the Filson Tin Cloth Cruiser for many different purposes and seasons. The jacket is made from 15-oz. oil-finished Tin Cloth, which is a densely woven cotton fabric that is impregnated with a proprietary oil-and-wax blend. This makes the fabric water-repellent, wind-resistant, and extremely durable.

Suga Cane is a rugged jacket that is inspired by vintage hunting garments from the 1940s-1950s. The jacket is made from 13-oz. brown duck canvas, which is a tightly woven cotton fabric that is dyed with natural indigo and sulfur. This gives the fabric a rich brown color that fades over time, creating a unique patina. Sugar Cane uses corduroy on collar, cuffs and pocket edges. The lining is olive cotton and linen that is attached only to the upper part of the back and the sleeves.


Filson comes with 6 engraved branded snap closures and two adjustable snap closures on each cuff and a rear map pocket that can be opened from both sides.

Sugar Cane has 4 buttons on the front and 1 on each cuff. Each button features a different animal avatar design. The fraying and peeling of the buttons enhance the retro feel. Buttons are secured with metal fittings so they can be removed when washing. Left breast pocket with vintage brass CONMATIC chain zipper. Eyelets at the underarms increase breathability, and pleats at the shoulders extend utility.

Although the reinforced stitching and pleats on the Sugar Cane shoulders adopt the details of the classic vintage hunting jacket, the Filson jacket has more shoulder room than the Sugar Cane.


Both jackets are made by reputable brands that are known for their high-quality products and craftsmanship. Filson is a company that has been making clothes and accessories for outdoor lovers since 1897. Whether you like to hunt, fish, explore, or adventure, you can find something that suits your needs at Filson. Their products are made to last and to protect you from harsh weather and terrain. They are also stylish and comfortable, so you can look good and feel good while enjoying nature. Sugar Cane is a Japanese company that was founded in 1975 and specializes in vintage-inspired clothing and denim. Sugar Cane’s products are made with authentic fabrics and techniques that recreate the look and feel of old-fashioned garments.

Both jackets are also made with premium materials that are sourced from reliable suppliers. Filson’s Tin Cloth is made from American-grown cotton that is woven by Cone Mills, one of the oldest denim manufacturers in the US. Filson’s oil-and-wax blend is made from paraffin wax and soybean oil that are refined by Martin Dyeing and Finishing Co., one of the last remaining dye houses in the US. Sugar Cane’s brown duck canvas is made from Egyptian cotton that is woven by Collect Co., one of the leading denim manufacturers in Japan. Sugar Cane’s indigo and sulfur dyes are made from natural ingredients that are processed by Kurabo Industries, one of the oldest textile companies in Japan.

Both jackets are also made with meticulous attention to detail and quality control. Filson’s Tin Cloth Cruiser is sewn by skilled workers in Filson’s own factory in Seattle, Washington. Each jacket undergoes rigorous inspection before being shipped to customers. Sugar Cane’s Brown Canvas Hunting Jacket is sewn by experienced workers in Sugar Cane’s own factory in Okayama, Japan. Each jacket is washed and dried several times to achieve the desired color and texture.


Both jackets have a regular fit that allows for layering and movement. However, there are some differences in their sizing and measurements. The Filson Tin Cloth Cruiser runs true to size and follows the standard American sizing chart. The jacket has a generous cut that accommodates different body types and shapes. The jacket also has some room for adjustment with its snap cuffs. The Sugar Cane Brown Canvas Hunting Jacket runs small and follows the Japanese sizing chart. The jacket has a slim cut that hugs the body more closely. The jacket also has less room for adjustment with its button cuffs and hem.

To help you make an informed choice, let’s explore how these two contenders compare across four essential categories: Fabric, Design, Quality, and Fit.

Filson vs Sugar Cane jacket comparison chart

In terms of Fabric, both jackets rise to the occasion. Filson’s Tin Cloth Cruiser slightly outshines with its oil-finished Tin Cloth that boasts durability and water repellency. The Sugar Cane Brown Canvas Hunting Jacket is no slouch either; its slightly lighter brown duck canvas imparts a unique vintage charm.

When we examine Design, Sugar Cane is the frontrunner, adorned with unique elements like animal avatar buttons, underarm eyelets, and vintage brass touches. In contrast, Filson opts for a more restrained yet functional approach, featuring engraved snap closures and adjustable cuffs.

Quality is a high point for both jackets, reflecting the manufacturers’ dedication to premium materials and meticulous craftsmanship. Both Filson and Sugar Cane put great care into their manufacturing processes, ensuring these jackets will endure.

Fit is another distinguishing factor. Filson offers a generous cut, accommodating different body shapes and layering preferences. Sugar Cane, on the other hand, opts for a closer, more body-conforming fit, in line with Japanese sizing standards, catering to those who favor a trim appearance.

In conclusion, your choice might boil down to specific preferences:

  • Filson Tin Cloth Cruiser: A perfect match for those valuing durability, water resistance, and a relaxed, timeless design.
  • Sugar Cane Brown Canvas Hunting Jacket: An appealing option for aficionados of vintage style, unique detailing, quality workmanship, and a slimmer fit.

Whatever your choice, both jackets offer something special, promising satisfaction and a style statement.

You can learn more about this topic by checking out some of our other related posts:

[Freewheelers Conductor Jacket vs Sugar Cane Railroad Coat]


Stan is an adventure enthusiast with a love for the outdoors and American heritage brands like Red Wing and Filson. With a background in environmental science, Stan combines his outdoor experiences with a commitment to sustainability. His reviews go beyond functionality, exploring the brand ethos and craftsmanship. Stan inspires readers to choose gear that's durable, environmentally responsible, and true to American craftsmanship, making his advice indispensable for outdoor aficionados.

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *